Stan, a friend of mine, and also co-author of the Muckraker Series, passed along a link to an article about the social significance, if any, of the hard-boiled detective/crime fiction genre. Thought it was an interesting read, although not sure I agree with the conclusions.
“Undergirding the entire genre is an understanding that those who guard money and power, hurting others in the process, are suspect. This is a basic premise that has driven crime fiction from Edgar Allen Poe to Scooby Do to Jessica Jones—and, fortuitously, it’s the same premise driving social justice movements today.”
Sometimes it seems the observers of creative activities often see hidden meaning in the results that never occurred to the creators. Although it is obvious no artist or writer creates their works in a vacuum; I think more often than not the end result is about little more than telling a story. The grand scheme of reflecting society is more by accident than intent.
Received a less than wonderful review on one of my books (Dog Gone Lies); where the reviewer seemed to think it was full of clichés.
What is a cliché?
“A cliché, or cliche, is an expression, idea, or element of an artistic work that has become overused to the point of losing its original meaning or effect, even to the point of being trite or irritating, especially when at some earlier time it was considered meaningful or novel.”
You could probably make a case that a murder mystery book, by design, is a cliché. Is that bad? Or maybe it was the main character being a retired rural sheriff? Overdone, maybe; but cliché? How about the huge Apache sidekick, who is also a computer guru? Or a Disbarred attorney, hiding from the bad guys, who drinks too much; that must be a cliché?
I think the reviewer probably thought that was a clever thing to write and had no idea how the book was a “cliché.” The reviewer should have just said he didn’t like the book. Straight forward and no way to argue with that, since it was just his opinion.
My books all deal with the power structure of our society; with an emphasis on cops, lawyers and political corruption. But each story is about individuals who are doing their best to survive in their world. Those individuals might be dealing with troubled grown children, or family histories that cause trauma in the next generation. Their lives could be mixed up with corrupt law enforcement or the ugly negative ripple of abuse. Or drugs and the depressing impact that has on so many. Also funny moments and loving moments. You know; life.
So is that a cliché?
I seemed to be spending more time lately dealing with edits of old books rather than writing new material. This is not my strength. (I hate it!) Some came about because of the Pacheco & Chino audio books. In preparation for the narration, several “typos” (or stupid mistakes) were discovered. As a result, those books went through another round of editing.
Some of these corrections are also the result of Amazon’s quality checks.
I have mixed feelings about Amazon. Without them the indie book world would not exist; with them it’s an autocratic approach to marketing that devalues any one product (book) for the benefit of Amazon. And why not? It’s their web site and they should be able to do anything they want. But, computer quality checks on books? When did we become so sensitive to typos?
Much of this gets back to the consumer. Most of my reviews are ok. But there are some, usually due to language, that feel unnecessarily ugly. Often these involve comments about errors–usually something along the lines of this writer needs to hire an editor. Internet reviews of all things have given a significant sense of power to many senseless people. By far the majority of my readers have received free books. I have distributed several hundred thousand free books so I could sell tens of thousands. With those number differences, it is logical the majority of my reviews are from people who spent zero on the book; and yet, they complain, and apparently complain to Amazon about errors. This isn’t a blender that does not work–it’s a creative work product. If you hate it, so what. But to complain about a few errors seems bizarre.
Obviously my writing about this is probably on the same level as those consumer complaints/reviews. Pointless.
I know this is a somewhat rambling post; but that fits my current mood. Everything seems disjointed. The world just feels out of sorts.
I’ve been uploading much of my older art to my new art web site. www.tedcliftonart.com. In the process I noticed several periods of intense activity. There are exceptions, but many of my paintings were done in those particular years; and all of those years represent bad times for me. Usually some kind of financial pickle that caused stress. Maybe creativity is a human way of dealing with unusual stress. If so there should be a bunch of creative works coming out very soon.
Look an ad for artwork; how did that happen?