
Most of my bad reviews for my books are because of foul, vile, filthy profanity. These reviews are few and offer a service to the people who are offended by certain language choices, so they are useful. Being useful to other readers who click on them locks them in at the top of the reviews, which annoys me, but it is what it is.
Some examples.
Could not read this book due to vile, filthy language.
When you have to open your story with profanity, you aren’t a good writer. I deleted this free book after reading the first line.
I’m not a prude, but the swearing was so over-the-top, it kept jarring me out of the story. I had to give up on this one.
I couldn’t get through the first page because of all the profanity. It might be a good story, but I will never know because of the crude language used by the author. He Should be able to write a book without stooping to profanity.
Those comments are typical. Most often the reviewer says that they read very little of the book. “Deleted this free book after reading the first line.” Wow, that first line must have had a punch. Deleting a free book has a strange ring to it—I’m writing you to demand a full refund of $0.00 due to your use of awful words! Another bad first impression, “couldn’t get through the first page.” These reviewers have every right (based on Amazon’s loose review requirements) to make their comments. But these are people who given the opportunity would censor everything. Not one little bad word, or vile image, or deceptive thought would escape these watchdogs for decency. I would also guess these people have strong opinions on how others dress, wear their hair or, heaven forbid, decorate their bodies. Being self-righteous seems to lead to the desire to control others. Being morally superior requires constant vigilance and diligence.
Many of these reviews are for the first two books published in 2015. At the time I wondered if I should have “toned-down” the choice of language (as suggested by one reviewer) to improve book sales. After only a little thought I decided that I had written the stories the way I thought they should be written and would live with the consequences of those choices.
The first book, The Bootlegger’s Legacy, opens with a prologue of a scene in a bar with gangsters talking about murdering the person they are waiting for, who is one of the main characters in the book. Gangsters talking about murder in a bar would be a very likely set of circumstances where there might be some profanity, duh?
Those first books were six years ago, and in that short time much of what is available on TV has more fucks in it than my books. Now you can say, well it’s cable, or streaming or whatever, but there it is in the living room for all to see and hear; one vile word after another. I have no way of measuring that, but my impression is that in those six years we went from a few choice words being said in some movies to a whole new level of “bad” word usage in almost all media.
Is that good or bad? The question is silly, of course, it’s not really either one. It just reflects our society as it exists for many if not most people.
Now the question could be was the change in the real world caused by the overuse of profanity in the entertainment world (including books), and now the justification for those language choices in the TV world is because that is the reality of the real world. Yep, I think there is some truth in that circle logic.
My parents were offended by certain language, me less so, my children even less so and my grandchildren wouldn’t be able to communicate without these offensive words, at least with their peers. Change is constant.
What offends me more than language is lying. Past generations have been lying about almost everything for hundreds if not thousands of years. In today’s world truth telling seems more akin to foul language. People are shunned for telling the truth. Famous people caught in lies blame someone else; I only lied because I was abused as a child, I only lied because I have a slight drinking problem caused by my medical condition, I only lied because it will all be forgotten and go away if I do not admit anything. Or the new classic, “I did not lie, you cannot believe what you saw me say on that video!”
All humans create myths to hide the truth. We have become so good at myth building that we’ve lost touch with the value of truth. “Tell it like it is” has been replaced with “say it until they believe it.”
The goal of my books is to tell an entertaining story, but also to tell a story that is believable. Truth (in a fictional way) is the goal and language, even vile language, is a part of that truth.

The new Grain-of-Salt Commentary Newsletter will publish Wednesday the 15th. The first edition will feature my article above and the premier article written by Ray Pacheco. Also includes a brief discussion on the value of changing book covers.
This free newsletter is distributed by email. You can sign up here. Thanks.






















